Critter: (noun, dialect.) A reader who undertakes to provide a constructive critique or helpful feedback on behalf of the author of the piece being read.

Critters are great. Critters are indispensable to my writing process, and I suspect that 90% of successful writers have critters of some sort.

Where to find good critters can be a difficult problem. Non-writer friends are often not the best critters, because they don’t always understand what kind of detail is helpful to a writer. Writer friends can make good critters, but not when they’re busy with writing first drafts of their own.

Critter exchanges can be a very good arrangement, or writer’s circles in which the entire group acts as critters for each of the members in turn.

I’ve found some good critter exchanges on the ‘Nano swaps’ forum of the National Novel Writing Month online community, and I’m attend two local writer’s groups that do critiques of pieces that members bring in. I’ve even acted as a critter wrangler for the Stringing Words online forum, organizing their third CritMo (Critter Month) event and pairing up authors with volunteer critters who read their pieces and send in feedback.

Recently, I’ve also joined an amazing online workshop called… (drum roll please,), which runs something like the same program on a much larger scale. Here’s how it works, basically:

  • I submit my formatted short story manuscript, either by email or through a form on the site.
  • My short story waits in line for several weeks, because there are a lot of other authors who have also submitted work to be critiqued and they only send out so many stories per week.
  • In the meantime, I look at the manuscripts that have been sent out and pick at least one per week, critique it, and send my thoughts via the website or email, from whence they’re forwarded to the author. There’s an accounting system that keeps track of how many critiques I’ve sent in per week, scoring that as a percentage.
  • Just before my story is about to be sent out for the critters to read and critique, the system checks my percentage score. If it’s 75% or lower, (meaning I haven’t at least sent in three critiques for every four months I’ve been a member,) my story gets put on hold, to be sent out some other week when I’ve improved my score.
  • People read my story, and send their thoughts through critters, which get emailed to me!
  • Everybody is VERY good about phrasing their thoughts diplomatically, because the critter Captain takes it very seriously if you start lecturing authors about how the three rules of writing are so-and-so and you’re doing this other thing wrong.

So – do you work as a critter for writers? If you’re a writer, where do you go to look for critters?

10 Responses to Critters

  1. Trisha says:

    YAY critters!!


  2. Pam says:

    Our writers’ group has been talking a lot lately about what makes a good “Critter”. Thanks for the timely post.


  3. Rogue Mutt says:

    I’ve used that before, but the wait is ridiculous. Usually I use Critique Circle anymore.


  4. I actually found my critters through nanowrimo’s site. They are the best anyone could ask for. 🙂


  5. So far I’ve done more critiquing than I’ve had critiquing done, although the last person who critiqued me gave me a very valid critique outlining both my strengths and my opportunities with writing.

    Found your blog via the A-Z Challenge. It’s a pleasure to meet you.


  6. Ivy Rutledge says:

    Finding people to critique your work is important, but I don’t necessarily think that they need to be writers. Unless your intended audience is other writers, it can be immensely helpful to get a reaction from someone in your target audience. On the other hand, having trained readers is good too. Over the years, my husband has learned how to read at the various stages of drafts, and having someone like this available is precious. A writer’s group is a good idea, but if that isn’t possible, having a handful of different kinds of people to read should be a good goal for every writer.


  7. Lucy Adams says:

    My husband is often my critter. He’s not a writer, but he represents the demosgraphic and grade level of my reader. So, if he says, “What the hell does this mean? You’re not making any sense,” then I know I need to do some editing.



  8. Jeanne Kraus says:

    OK love this. Love calling them critters. It took me a minute to figure out that you were not talking about my cat and dog! Funny. A critter is so important. I can’t tell you how many times I have taken my story, thinking I am done, to my group and having them tear it apart, and rightfully so. Could not do without them.


  9. Michael says:

    I need a critique circle.


  10. alberta ross says:

    my ‘bestest’friend of nearly 60 yrs is my critter – and editor – and ghost word finder and ‘you called him joe on page 20’ policeman! workds well for me – she has accepted my style and works with it to knock grammar and sense into the writing


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: